eagle Wm. Rogers star on bottom of creamer. Is it plate?

Hello again,
I have a small creamer that has this[pictured] on the bottom. I thought it is plated but I filed down heavily on a corner and am still acid testing silver only. Before I ruin it, would any one know if this is silver or plated?
Thanks again for your time and any answers,
Karl.

 

If its Rogers and it doesn't say sterling, it is plate...............Rogers (in any incarnation) made comparatively little sterling and it is always marked as such.

Their stuff is above average quality for plate, so I am not surprised that you are not down to the base metal (yet).

 

how does a round creamer....have a corner ? ... bawhahaha!!!!!!

always ask here 1st before putting file to metal !

 

The original (eagle) Rogers (star) mark goes back a long way, but this is not one of those. This is mid-20th century plate.

 

Is this your creamer?




Pattern is Spring Flower - Silverplate

 

Here is a pict.
Thanks for the replies. I didn't think it was silver but better to ask for help then be wrong.
Karl.

 

Ah ha! See you already know MORE than I did when I started here......................