Featured Antique andirons help

Discussion in 'Antique Discussion' started by djs259, Oct 7, 2023.

  1. djs259

    djs259 New Member

    Hello everyone. This is my first post to the forum.

    So I recently purchased these old lemon top brass andirons. I believe they may be from the 19th century, but I'm not certain. Is there any way to determine when they were made? Does anyone have a ballpark figure as to what they might be worth?
     

    Attached Files:

    Figtree3, judy and johnnycb09 like this.
  2. komokwa

    komokwa The Truth is out there...!

    Bakersgma and sabre123 like this.
  3. Bakersgma

    Bakersgma Well-Known Member

    They do not look like they have ever been used in a fireplace.
     
  4. Debora

    Debora Well-Known Member

    No they don't. Perhaps they've never been used in a lit fireplace.

    Debora
     
  5. djs259

    djs259 New Member

    So anyone have any idea about approximate age on these?
     
  6. antidiem

    antidiem Well-Known Member

    My best guess would be 1980s.
     
  7. djs259

    djs259 New Member

    What makes you think that?
     
  8. djs259

    djs259 New Member

    I would think these would be a lot older?
     
  9. komokwa

    komokwa The Truth is out there...!

    What makes you think that ?
     
    BoudiccaJones likes this.
  10. djs259

    djs259 New Member

    Well, just the style and dark color of the patina on the brass, as well as the fact that the legs don't appear to be secured by a simple threaded bolt as would be the case with more recently made andirons. Plus the heavy weight of these andirons doesn't seem consistent with something that was made in the 1980's. Also, I've seen photos of very similar looking andirons posted online described as being from the late 19th century. Does anyone here have accurate information on this?
     
  11. djs259

    djs259 New Member

  12. verybrad

    verybrad Well-Known Member

    The problem with something like this is that they have been made forever. Very hard to tell how old these are. I am not seeing the kind of wear and tear, nor patina I would expect to see from 120+ years of use. Were they made in 1980s or 1950s? Could be either but I would guess sometime in that time period.

    Here are a couple examples that do exhibit the wear and tear of 120+ years. The first remain unsold at $150.00. The second sold for $70.00.

    ANTIQUE FEDERAL BRASS ANDIRONS LEMON TOP WITH BALL AND CLAW FEET | eBay

    Pair Boston Lemon Top Brass Andirons - Oct 04, 2015 | Schwenke Auctioneers In Ct (liveauctioneers.com)

    Here is a much older pair sold by a well respected auction house that should know their stuff. Even though polished, they exhibit the patina one would expect to find. Sold for $200.00

    Pair Federal Brass Andirons - May 30, 2009 | Brunk Auctions In Nc (liveauctioneers.com)
     
  13. djs259

    djs259 New Member

    Thank you for your input


    QUOTE="verybrad, post: 9557190, member: 37"]The problem with something like this is that they have been made forever. Very hard to tell how old these are. I am not seeing the kind of wear and tear, nor patina I would expect to see from 120+ years of use. Were they made in 1980s or 1950s? Could be either but I would guess sometime in that time period.

    Here are a couple examples that do exhibit the wear and tear of 120+ years. The first remain unsold at $150.00. The second sold for $70.00.

    ANTIQUE FEDERAL BRASS ANDIRONS LEMON TOP WITH BALL AND CLAW FEET | eBay

    Pair Boston Lemon Top Brass Andirons - Oct 04, 2015 | Schwenke Auctioneers In Ct (liveauctioneers.com)

    Here is a much older pair sold by a well respected auction house that should know their stuff. Even though polished, they exhibit the patina one would expect to find. Sold for $200.00

    Pair Federal Brass Andirons - May 30, 2009 | Brunk Auctions In Nc (liveauctioneers.com)[/QUOTE]
     
    komokwa likes this.
  14. djs259

    djs259 New Member

    Kind of disappointed rn tbh
     
  15. komokwa

    komokwa The Truth is out there...!

    don't be........ they're very nice and the price was good !!;) :happy:
     
    djs259 likes this.
  16. verybrad

    verybrad Well-Known Member

    I think it is a supply vs. demand kind of thing with andirons. Have to think that a very large percentage of andirons made in the last 200 years have survived. They are durable and tend to be kept. Add to that, they are not nearly as much in demand as they once were. There are a lot of very nice examples available for very little money.
     
    johnnycb09, djs259 and komokwa like this.
  17. komokwa

    komokwa The Truth is out there...!

    I still have one or two sets of andirons....and my brass firebox border.....but haven't had a fireplace since '88,,,
     
    johnnycb09 and verybrad like this.
  18. Jeff Drum

    Jeff Drum Well-Known Member

    Antique brass (andirons, candlesticks) has been duplicated since first made. To distinguish antiques from repro requires looking closely at construction details. I would not buy based on a couple pics online - none of the links shown by brad look likely to be authentic to me, the first two definitely not, third can’t tell from that one pic but I’m skeptical. The OP ones shown are certainly 20th century, not antique, and agree with mid 20th or later.

    Indeed the demand for andirons is terrible, the supply is huge, and most people can’t tell the difference (or don’t care). So I have found it is pretty easy to pick up authentic ones for peanuts here in New England. New housing rarely has even one fireplace, even here in New England. We have six fireplaces in one home, and three in another, so I have accumulated a lot of andirons over the years and studied how to tell the difference. But as with most antiques these days, most people buy on the appearance, and simply don’t care about authenticity.
     
    judy, Any Jewelry, verybrad and 2 others like this.
  19. techbiker

    techbiker Well-Known Member

    And if the construction methods are similar enough, a lowish price for the antique version is probably justified! Sometimes age doesn't confer much extra value.

    When I stopped by a local thrift store 2 months ago, I saw entire antique metal-rimmed English China sets gathering dust at ~$55. Newer microwave-safe dishes were selling at double the price per piece. Tastes and demands change!
     
    judy, Any Jewelry, johnnycb09 and 2 others like this.
  20. antidiem

    antidiem Well-Known Member

    Having purchased MANY andiron sets on the cheap for inexpensive resale years ago makes me think that. I guess they could be 1970s, but they look 80s to me.

    No need, even in a warm southern climate, I found I could easily sell them on any venue or at a consignment shop for more than I paid for them, so I always bought them even if they weren't old. Most that I bought were not old. These are a lovely example, you didn't do badly, it's a steep learning curve.
     
    judy, johnnycb09 and djs259 like this.
Draft saved Draft deleted
Similar Threads: Antique andirons
Forum Title Date
Antique Discussion Some Antique railway item? Oct 20, 2024
Antique Discussion antique mortar??? Oct 13, 2024
Antique Discussion I have an antique wall clock that I need info on. Oct 12, 2024
Antique Discussion The one antique you'd give up all of your others for. Oct 1, 2024
Antique Discussion Anyone know anything about this antique wood wall bracket? Sep 29, 2024

Share This Page