Chinese Soapstone Ornament Vase (Flowers, Plants, Bird)

Discussion in 'Antique Discussion' started by R. Antonis, May 15, 2017.

  1. R. Antonis

    R. Antonis Well-Known Member

    Hi everybody!,

    Could anyone tell me more about the age of this piece?

    -Origin: Chinese.
    -Age: ???
    -Material: Soapstone.
    -Pictured: Flowers/Plants/Bird.

    *Height: 34,7 cm/ 13,66 inch.
    *Width: 17,6 cm/ 6,92 inch.
    *Depth: 12 cm/ 4,72 inch.
    *Weight: 4 KG.

    Thank you very much!!

    20170515_174614.jpg 20170515_174556.jpg 20170515_174545.jpg 20170515_174532.jpg 20170515_174507.jpg
     
  2. Ownedbybear

    Ownedbybear Well-Known Member

    Chinese, yes. They've been made for centuries - I don't think yours has much age. It looks relatively mass carved.
     
    R. Antonis likes this.
  3. Any Jewelry

    Any Jewelry Well-Known Member

    Vintage to only just antique.
    These decorative vases were usually made in pairs, and they are not rare. The exact age is hard to determine, but given the fragility of the material, most of them are vintage rather than antique.
    The value is in artistry and condition, and a pair is worth more than 2x1. Yours, although pretty, is not at the top of the range, and it has lost its companion.
    To get an idea:
    https://www.ebth.com/items/5533095-chinese-carved-soapstone-vase
    http://www.ebay.com/itm/Pair-of-Vin...gn-China-Pr-/371931253587?hash=item5698d48b53
     
    Last edited: May 15, 2017
    judy and R. Antonis like this.
  4. tyeldom3

    tyeldom3 Well-Known Member

    My mom has one just like it and it was purchased in a mall in an Asian store in the mid to late 1970's.
     
  5. R. Antonis

    R. Antonis Well-Known Member

    I really expected it to be much older.
    Are there any things I should pay attention to next time I pay a soapstone piece?
     
  6. khl889

    khl889 Well-Known Member

    This is Qingtian stone from Zhejiang province. I think it dates to the period of the Chinese Republic, say 1920s or 30s or 40s.

    Basically a nice piece in terms of carving, but the particular range of stone used is not very interesting. Some Qingtian stones have colors and patterns that are very attractive. So when buying Qingtian carvings, look for eye-catching stone, not something dull. It really is the particular stone that gives value. (Of course, beware of stones may have been dyed and repaired, especially on newer pieces.)

    Like cloisonné, these are generally regarded as mass-produced crafts and don't attract too much collector interest, and there are lot of them out there. So prices tend not to be too good unless the piece is exceptional.
     
  7. R. Antonis

    R. Antonis Well-Known Member

    That makes perfect sense :) Thank you very much!
     
    judy likes this.
  8. Ownedbybear

    Ownedbybear Well-Known Member

    khl, how do you date these? I find it quite tricky to distinguish between the Republic ones and some more modern.
     
    judy and tyeldom3 like this.
  9. khl889

    khl889 Well-Known Member

    Look at the stone itself; different types were mined at different times.The particular types of stone used in the 1930s are now mined out.

    Look at the condition; the original wax polish slowly degrades over time.

    Look at the carving; certain styles were more popular at different times. As well, in the Republic era Qingtian carvings were largely marketed at Westerners while in more recent times Chinese are the major customers. The OP's piece is Western in style and that's a very strong indication this dates to before 1949.

    Look at a museum collection, like the one near Qingtian.
     
    cxgirl, Any Jewelry, judy and 5 others like this.
  10. Ownedbybear

    Ownedbybear Well-Known Member

    Thank you very much indeed, that's really useful and is going in my long term memory. ;)
     
    judy, tyeldom3 and R. Antonis like this.
  11. 808 raver

    808 raver Well-Known Member

    Hi I wonder if you had any idea on this little soapstone teapot? I know it came from my great Aunty who was a Victorian collector DSCF2330 (Medium).JPG DSCF2331 (Medium).JPG DSCF2332 (Medium).JPG
     
    tyeldom3 likes this.
  12. khl889

    khl889 Well-Known Member

    On the one hand, yours has nicer stone than the OP's, with some color, a pattern, and a bit of translucency.

    On the other hand, it doesn't seem all that well made; even the lid doesn't match. Looks a bit mass-produced.

    It's hard to be too certain, but my impression is yours dates somewhat later than the OP's, and could even date to around the 1980s. That greenish stone in the rear section was very common then.

    (I'll add that if you search for "Qingtian carving" on Google Images you can compare the results with these two examples; Qingtian stone has become scarcer in recent years, and most modern carvings are fairly elaborate and fairly expensive.)
     
    Last edited: May 16, 2017
  13. R. Antonis

    R. Antonis Well-Known Member

    I saw somebody in my neighbourhood put this next piece online today.
    I think it's some kind of incense burner. Would you also consider this a dull piece, since the stone's basically just one color?

    117.JPG 116.JPG 115.JPG 114.JPG 112.JPG
     
  14. Any Jewelry

    Any Jewelry Well-Known Member

    I wouldn't buy it, but I generally steer away from soapstone. I'd rather buy jade or another hardstone. I sometimes make an exception for a nice piece of Shoushan stone.
    And yes, the coulour and quality of carving are not overly appealing.
     
  15. R. Antonis

    R. Antonis Well-Known Member

    I already expected that. But if you didn't tell me that earlier I would thought it was something special I guess.

    Just today I was (half-)watching an online auction with many shoushan and jade pieces. It was an live auction, where you could just see 1 picture of the item, with a title, without description.

    Of course the description existed, but therefore you had to click every item and load in a new lot-page, while the auction was going on. So I didn't really learn much.

    I just saw price go up & down, not really knowing why one piece was so special and the other, to me as a beginner, which colors looked quite the same wasn't.
     
  16. 808 raver

    808 raver Well-Known Member

    I agree, it isn't that well carved, I know nothing about soapstone, everything in that cabinet came from her, as to the date, I expect it's the same age as all the rest of the stuff, late 19c, she died in the 70's. I have looked online and there are many of the same type (not expensive :( ) thanks for the info
     
  17. Any Jewelry

    Any Jewelry Well-Known Member

    It is a collector's market, so knowing what collectors actually look for is the clue to understanding the market. Watching what items make at auction is one way.
    Good quality stone and good quality carving is important. Preferably highly detailed.
    Attractive subjects like beautifully dressed elegant young ladies do better than toothless old men.
    Sometimes it is difficult to understand what is attractive, for instance an exquisitely carved Chinese jade cabbage will often sell for more than a beautifully carved flower. Probably because cabbage is a symbol of wealth, part of the Chinese word for cabbage sounds the same as the word for money. They also were a favourite of the empress dowager Cixi.

    If you are interested in Qingtian stone objects, here is a site with info and some beautiful quality carvings:
    http://chinacoolart.com/2015/02/26/qingtian-stone-sculpture/
     
    judy and 808 raver like this.
  18. R. Antonis

    R. Antonis Well-Known Member

    @Any Jewelry : Thank you very much for the information. I'm going to check out the website immediately :)
     
Draft saved Draft deleted
Similar Threads: Chinese Soapstone
Forum Title Date
Antique Discussion Chinese? Carved Soapstone Stylized Lion; Older? Feb 16, 2023
Antique Discussion Chinese soapstone? Jan 31, 2023
Antique Discussion Chinese Lamp Figure , Stone Face Carving (India? Soapstone?), & Old Bowl (Japanese?) Sep 25, 2022
Antique Discussion Chinese Soapstone Brushwasher Mar 18, 2022
Antique Discussion Green Chinese Snuff Bottle Resin or Soapstone Sep 18, 2020

Share This Page