Mixed metal (Japanese ?) vase.

Discussion in 'Metalware' started by quirkygirl, Aug 15, 2015.

  1. quirkygirl

    quirkygirl likes pretty old things

    About 6" (14.5 cm) high, weighing about a pound ... no markings.

    Beautiful inlay work looks like tarnished silver to me ... afraid to polish it.

    The only other similar vase (in both shape and inlaid design) I found was a slightly taller one recently sold in Taiwan at auction - Identified as from Japan ... Edo period.
    https://www.liveauctioneers.com/item/37837081_a-silver-inlaid-bronze-vase

    I don't like to just identify an item with only one reference.
    Can anyone help to ID this? Anyone familiar with this type of work?

    My vase:
    P1080178.JPG P1080181.JPG P1080179.JPG P1080183.JPG P1080166.JPG
     

    Attached Files:

    Pat P likes this.
  2. Figtree3

    Figtree3 What would you do if you weren't afraid?

    Pretty! I'm not sure why nobody else has replied yet. Maybe the right person has not been here.
     
    quirkygirl likes this.
  3. quirkygirl

    quirkygirl likes pretty old things

    Thanks for responding, Fig! :)
    I too am hopeful that someone will recognize the style or work of this piece. Even if it is just to give advise on whether to polish or not.
     
  4. komokwa

    komokwa The Truth is out there...!

    Here's the thing....& I'm no expert on Asian metal, but to my eye yours looks like a more recent copy of the one you found on line.
    The black one is elegant & has that sublime understated oriental look.....& yours doesn't.
    I realize that's my gut feeling and not very informative.....but it's what I see.:peeking::peeking:
     
    quirkygirl likes this.
  5. quirkygirl

    quirkygirl likes pretty old things

    Thank you, komokwa. I appreciate any and all opinions about the vase - good, bad, or indifferent - as I am basically clueless ... so you certainly have more experience than I. ;)

    When I see something that I've no knowledge of, I buy it so that I may learn from it (as long as it is not too expensive and attractive enough that I can live with it - should it turn out to be something in which only I see the beauty)

    Neither the vase from the auction nor mine show much, if any, base wear ... seems odd for items as heavy as this.
     
    komokwa likes this.
  6. afantiques

    afantiques Well-Known Member

    It does look more Indian than Japanese to me, but that's just a feeling too.
     
    quirkygirl likes this.
  7. Pat P

    Pat P Well-Known Member

    I also get a Near/Middle East vibe from it and like the its graceful shape and pattern.
     
    quirkygirl likes this.
  8. komokwa

    komokwa The Truth is out there...!

    How would you compare it to the black & silver one in the link ??
     
  9. quirkygirl

    quirkygirl likes pretty old things

    Thanks af and Pat for both your input.

    When I first picked it up, Japan wasn't even a contender of places where this could have originated ... more like Persia or Morocco - since the inlay reminded me of the mosaic tile work associated with those places. Which is why I questioned the validity of that auction house attributing theirs (with the almost exact inlay design) to Japan.

    Oh ... by the way ... I went ahead and shined her up (please, don't scold ... the tarnish hadn't been on there that long ... I could easily get that look back by putting it in a room with my husband for a few days ;) )

    P1080188.JPG
     
    Pat P likes this.
  10. Savvy*Spyglass*Treasures

    Savvy*Spyglass*Treasures Fancy Endeavours. That's my user ID on eBay now.

    It reminds me of the "I Dream of Jeannie" bottle without the stopper, of course! :)

    Juli
     
    quirkygirl likes this.
  11. komokwa

    komokwa The Truth is out there...!

    Now yours looks more like the one in the link...??
    Which means...........I dunno ???
     
    quirkygirl likes this.
  12. anundverkaufen

    anundverkaufen Bird Feeder

    Bidriware.
     
    quirkygirl likes this.
  13. springfld.arsenal

    springfld.arsenal Store: http://www.springfieldarsenal.net/

    Ooohhhhh Noooooo! It'th woooooined!

    Jes' kiddin. It does look like a recent import decorator/souvenir item. Workmanship is only fair. I'm sure it is worth what you paid for it, worth that to you anyway.
     
    quirkygirl likes this.
  14. quirkygirl

    quirkygirl likes pretty old things

    Yes yes yes!!!!

    Thank you anundverkaufen! Mwuah!

    That's the magic word! So many similar vases when searched with that word!

    You rock! :) :) :)
     
    anundverkaufen likes this.
  15. quirkygirl

    quirkygirl likes pretty old things

    Ha ha .... very funny!

    I'll be OK. I do feel sorry for the winning bidder in the Taiwanese auction that I linked above .... paying roughly the equivalent $1000 USD for what looks very similar to mine (my photos are not good at all ... the workmanship on mine is better than it appears in the photos)
     
  16. komokwa

    komokwa The Truth is out there...!

    it looks much better now...
     
  17. FredZ

    FredZ Member

    The vase is bidri ware and is silver in-bedded into a zinc alloy.
     
    Figtree3 likes this.
  18. quirkygirl

    quirkygirl likes pretty old things

    You are correct, Fred! Another member had already ID'd this earlier as such, but I certainly thank you for trying to help me! Glad to see that you're still hanging around the forum with us. :)
     
    komokwa likes this.
Similar Threads: Mixed metal
Forum Title Date
Metalware Cancerous Japanese mixed metal vase age help Mar 11, 2023
Metalware Mixed Metal Parrot-Abalone Inlay. Value and Maker Apr 28, 2022
Metalware Japanese Mixed Metal Charger w/Immortals - Signed Feb 24, 2022
Metalware Japanese-Signed Mixed Metal Vse With Silver Trees-Mountains-I.D.Help? Jul 19, 2020
Metalware Japanese metal/mixed metal Oni tray Mar 7, 2020

Share This Page