Featured Please help me to check “Galle” glass vase

Hello dear users, please help me to check authenticity of this Galle glass vase.

 

Sweet vase, but not Gallé.
There is a Romanian company that makes Gallé style vases. Maybe it is by them, although their quality is generally a bit better.

 

https://www.invaluable.com/auction-...h-1846-1904-cameo-glass-vase-118-c-fee4729bab

Found this overall similar,but the overall quality/detail looks better than yours. Thinking yours is a reproduction but very nice looking.

 

How To Identify Fake Galle Vases | Galle Art Glass

authentication guide and offer for ID fake or real...

 

I would like to ask you what you think about the signature. and what are the years of reproductions?

 

I sent an email yesterday and they told me it was authentic so currently I am a little bit confused

 

Thanks for the link. Will definitely read that..

 

Well then good for you. They must be sure,if they are willing to say that without an inspection. I wasn’t sure about the quality (but what donI know!!)

Are you selling it to them?

 

No, I am collecting some rare antique glass products currently not for sale

 

Reproduction to my eye. Anytime the G in Galle' looks like a Y..... Saw similar offered for sale in the early 90s.

 

Yes, with names like Galle, Lalique and perhaps Daum Nancy, there are imitations, reproductions and out and out fakes. So, for authentication, I would rely on a good dealer, auction house or even a university department. However, before that, I would probably peruse Google and ebay, etc. for research into reproductions.

 

more...or less confused now ????

I think we have a winner !!!!!!


https://www.nesteggantiques.co.uk/a...lle-cameo-glass-lily-vase-nancy-c1905-12-579/




.

 

Totally Confused now maybe it is good quality reproduction or bad authentic product.

 

Iam definitely in that boat!

 

the guide says it's good.....the Antiques store says it's good.... and Komo says it's good.....
I'd go with that until some expert says ...it's not !

 

Reproductions became very common from the 70s forward. The Romanian versions will also say “tip” (“type”) somewhere on the piece. They were good quality versions, but not at the same level of execution as the originals.

Yours seems like a reproduction. The decorative detail is not as subtle and nuanced as one would expect from an original, the neck contour seems “wobbly,” and the top edge seems sharper rather than rounded as one finds in the genuine article. Also keep in mind that dealers can be fooled like the rest of us.

Nevertheless, if you didn’t pay too much for this it’s a nice and perfectly serviceable cameo vase. Fakes are now just as common as originals or more so.
We all hope for a bargain, but what usually happens is you get what you pay for (if you’re lucky) and Galle vases are pricey.

 

I vote reproduction . Weve all bought one of those at some point.

 

Does anyone have some information about Anton Klieber? If yes I would like help in this discussion:https://www.antiquers.com/threads/austrian-porcelain-“anton-klieber-braut”-figure.85424/

 

Well,this is turning out to be a most interesting roller coaster of a discussion. Thanks all

 

I got answer from them right now more confused